Gantry . evaluation record

79 robot datasets, graded one at a time

Each report below takes a public robot dataset and measures one property of it across every episode. Where an arm was trained, the worst-scoring part is removed and the result retrained; where it was not, the report states a counted property of the release and claims no lift. The corpus figures, the defect rates, the cuts and the clips are computed from the releases themselves.

datasets graded
79
in 88 published reports
episodes examined
2,213,165
every one scored
episodes removed
123,143
5.6% of the total
rollouts graded
30,020
234 tasks
clips cut
218
from the releases
measured claims
349
each traced to a file

Every dataset

Sorted by fit. The bar is the share of that corpus the cut removes, drawn on a common scale, so the datasets carrying the most dead weight stand out. Everything left of the lift column is computed from the release. The lift column is read from each report's fine tune table rather than from a training run.

#OwnerDatasetExamined What the measurement foundRemoved LiftClips
3GigaAIZheng ZhuGigaBrain-0.7 Sample1,3726 of 25 Action dimensions that never move across all 163,819 push…17.1%+5.28
6MetricHrant DavtyanRoboArena DataDump 02-03-20269,58988.9% Rollouts where binary_success is 0, so the ranking rests…12.9%+5.48
7GalbotZhizheng ZhangSynGrasp-1B17,54027% pick_up_propeller, 17 of 63 episodes flagged failed.3.3%+5.38
8IndependentMarius CobzarencoCommunity Curated v050,59212.6% Share of the one-camera episodes the cut takes, against 1…2.7%+5.18
10Furhat RoboticsGabriel SkantzeHRI CUES Dataset, Anonymized59024.9% 147 exchanges where all three experts wrote the same scor…19.0%+5.20
12OdysseyJeff HawkeCaliBench1,15294.2% 1,052 of the release's 1,117 legible outcomes survive.44.4%+5.08
13HumanSignal (Label Studio)Max TkachenkoInternData-A1 ARX Lift-2236,19142 Distinct action records behind their 1,708 episodes, one…1.0%+5.28
14The Robot Learning CompanyJannik GrothusenTRLC DK1 t-shirt folding5324 Takes whose commanded gripper never opens or closes once.3.9%+5.08
15Trossen RoboticsLuke SchmittTrossen AI LeRobot releases56014.5% Frames where no arm joint and no gripper is commanded pas…10.5%+5.29
16Hugging FaceNicolas Rabaultcommunity_dataset_v31,755165 Contributors shipping the byte-identical task sentence. T…14.1%+5.38
18Viam RoboticsEliot Horowitzbox-opener1102.5x Fastest demonstration against slowest, same task string,…17.3%+5.78
21RerunEmil Ernerfeldtso101-pick-and-place52,79624.3s 70 of the 72 takes land inside 702 to 736 frames, standar…39.2%+5.48
22TIER IV North AmericaYutaka KondoIKNet Open Manipulator X41,94498.0% Distinct 5 mm end effector cells still covered after the…8.9%+5.20
23Overland AIJames HaysArgoverse 2 Sensor1,701,9351,427 Tracks carrying the identical cuboid 4.03 by 1.74 by 1.41…4.7%+5.89
24Agility RoboticsChris Paxtoncpaxton/pickup_pink_cup2,587125 Episode 7 holds the gripper command at 0.6000, its fully…10.1%+5.28
25Horizon RoboticsZhizhong SuInstructMove Dataset5007 of 14 Dimensions holding at most two values from an episode's f…60.0%+4.68
26iRootechYang LiuCFG-Bench9,61525.6% Down from 47.2% over the whole multiple choice set.34.1%+5.28
27XPENG RoboticsChenPhysicalAI-Robotics-GR00T-Teleop-…24,00010% All 24 directories declare 1,000 episodes and ship a decl…1.1%+5.28
28TIER IVJacob LambertTIER IV t4-sample65845.8% 44 of the 96 boxes whose own label reads no occlusion of…22.9%+5.60
38Menlo ResearchNicole ZhuMenlo Robot Hand Poses11,0002 of 24 lh_WRJ2 spans 0.0006 rad and lh_WRJ1 spans 0.0165 rad acr…20.8%+5.58
39gBionicsGiulio RomualdiCMU Motion Capture Library, FBX2,5481,096 Of the 1,100 distinct labels in the release, still covere…15.6%+4.90
40Nanyang Technological Uni…Shenghai YuanUAVScenes key-frame release24,12615.6% HKairport_GNSS03 gives up 98 of its 630 labeled frames. A…7.0%+5.48
41OpenDriveLab, University…Hongyang LiFreeTacMan6,428333x Peak TCP position tops out at 0.594 across the off-scale…12.4%+4.98
42Shanda / AlayaKaipeng ZhangWildWorld part 13,434133 Of the 349 episodes under the motion threshold, 133 also…10.7%+5.20
43Korea Maritime and Ocean…Woen-Sug ChoiSmall Underwater Objects 3D Point…1,55447.3% Object class recovered from the byte size of point_cloud.…8.4%+5.48
44Nissan Advanced Technolog…Jash Shahlerobot/pusht2060 Frames out of 25,650 where next.success is true, while pe…25.7%+5.58
45RerunMichael Gruppv30_apple_storage89916.7x meta/info.json declares 14,983 frames and a train split o…58.4%+5.38
46MuRobotics (HandUMI)Brik H. Mezamurobotics/tblock-all-piper-clean…1760 of 176 Episodes where right_gripper.pos never changes. The narro…51.1%+5.08
47University of QueenslandHumphrey MunnRAPT G1 OOD Benchmark6,7030.993 Log duration by itself separates the 39 anomalous real ro…10.6%+5.20
48Physical IntelligenceJimmy Tanneraloha_pen_uncap_diverse123300 All 123 episodes are exactly 300 frames, a 6.00 second wi…15.4%+5.38
49Princeton University and…Anirudha MajumdarPlayWorld human demonstration data925925 of 925 The per-episode success field reads 1 on every episode in…15.1%+4.88
50Holiday RoboticsHojoon Leerobocasa-PnPCounterToSink-MG_100_…57282.5% 472 of 572 episodes are exactly 700 frames long and stop…55.2%+5.48

The findings in full

The measured headline from each report, with the corpus it came from.

GigaBrain-0.7 SampleGigaAI . 6 Sep 2026

We graded open-gigaai/GigaBrain-0.7-SampleData, the 1,372-episode release your team put out with the GigaBrain-0.7 report. In each push_button subset 6 of the 25 action dimensions never move across any frame, three of them holding exactly one value, and 105 of the 360 push button episodes hold the entire right arm still from first frame…

17%
Removed
60 minutes of 5.6 hours
6 of 25
Constant everywhere
3 exactly flat . 3 under 1e-3 rad
cut 234 of 1,372 (17.1%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 120 rollouts7 measured claims
RoboArena DataDump 02-03-2026Metric . 6 Sep 2026

We went through RoboArena DataDump 02-03-2026, one of the fourteen sources FailBench selects and grades under the labels its own recorders assigned. Scoring every rollout by its uncredited seconds, meaning recorded time times one minus partial_success, 1,237 of the 9,589 leave at least a full 399 step cap uncredited, and 534 of those are…

12.9%
Removed
534 of them a single policy
88.9%
Scored zero
54.6% of the preference labels one evaluator
cut 1,237 of 9,589 (12.9%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 120 rollouts12 measured claims
SynGrasp-1BGalbot . 6 Sep 2026

We graded vegebirrd/SynGrasp-1B, the corpus your GraspVLA paper curates and the PKU-EPIC README links to. In 17,540 episodes read from 12 of the 1,256 shards, 583 carry episode.success false and ship anyway, and they concentrate hard, pick_up_propeller loses 17 of 63 and pick_up_tennis_racket 14 of 53 while 92 of the 294 object classes n…

3.3%
Removed
81 minutes of 40.3 hours
27%
Worst object class
corpus rate 3.3% . 92 of 294 classes never fail
cut 583 of 17,540 (3.3%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 120 rollouts9 measured claims
Community Curated v0Independent . 6 Sep 2026

We graded your Community Curated v0, all 981 sub-datasets and 52,507 episodes and 229.5 hours of it. Giving every judged episode one number, the share of its judge-labelled frames where the gripper and the manipulated object are both in shot, 1,365 episodes come in below half and 160 sit at zero, meaning the camera never shows the work a…

2.6%
Removed
628,515 frames . 5.8 hours
12.6%
One camera
5,584 one-camera episodes . 701 removed
cut 1,365 of 50,592 (2.7%) across 3 groups8 clips8 tasks x 120 rollouts10 measured claims
HRI CUES Dataset, AnonymizedFurhat Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded HRI CUES, the Zenodo release you are a named creator on, recorded on a Furhat robot. Every one of its 590 exchanges carries three expert enjoyment scores, and only 147 of them are unanimous, while on 112, 19.0%, the panel splits by two or more points on a five point scale. Training the scorer without those 112 beat training on…

19.0%
Removed
36.7 of 174.4 minutes
24.9%
Unanimous
76.7% of labels are a 3 or a 4
cut 112 of 590 (19.0%) across 4 groups0 clips5 tasks x 120 rollouts8 measured claims
CaliBenchOdyssey . 6 Sep 2026

We ran your team's CaliBench release through Gantry, all 1,728 committed rollouts across the 54 scene and model cells. Scoring each cell by how many of its 32 generations carry a legible outcome, 16 cells come out under half and those 16 hold 447 of the release's 611 illegible generations, so dropping 29.6% of the corpus still keeps 1,05…

29.6%
Removed
447 of them carry no legible outcome
94.2%
Legible outcomes kept
the removed 512 held 65 . 12.7% of themselves
cut 512 of 1,152 (44.4%) across 4 groups8 clips9 tasks x 150 rollouts11 measured claims
InternData-A1 ARX Lift-2HumanSignal (Label Studio) . 6 Sep 2026

Michael's post on the robot data problem names InternData-A1, so we graded it, all 382 ARX Lift-2 subsets and 236,191 episodes of the LeRobot v3 build. 2,328 episodes carry an action record that is bit identical to another episode sitting next to it in the same subset, and the three folding subsets are most of it, 1,708 episodes holding…

42
The folding subsets
1,708 head camera streams . all different
cut 2,328 of 236,191 (1.0%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 120 rollouts8 measured claims
TRLC DK1 t-shirt foldingThe Robot Learning Company . 6 Sep 2026

We went through Gongsta/trlc_tshirt_folding, the dataset your TRLC Data Explorer lists first, recorded on DK1 arms by a customer rather than published by you. Four of its 532 takes ship with a commanded gripper that never opens or closes for the whole recording, and those four are the four shortest takes in the set, the shortest 7 frames…

3.9%
Removed
33,337 frames of 1,106,053
4
Dead takes
the 4 shortest of 532 . 7 frames, 0.23 s
cut 21 of 532 (3.9%) across 4 groups8 clips4 tasks x 180 rollouts11 measured claims
Trossen AI LeRobot releasesTrossen Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We went through the eleven LeRobot v2.1 datasets published under TrossenRoboticsCommunity on Hugging Face, 560 episodes and 349,886 frames on Trossen AI arms. Capture stops on a timer and not on the task, so 14.5% of all action frames are an arm commanded to hold position, 56 episodes run five seconds or more past their last commanded mo…

10.5%
Removed
51,207 frames . 28.4 minutes
14.5%
Held in place
50,604 of 349,886 frames . 28.1 minutes
cut 59 of 560 (10.5%) across 4 groups9 clips6 tasks x 100 rollouts8 measured claims
community_dataset_v3Hugging Face . 6 Sep 2026

We graded lerobot/community_dataset_v3, the corpus your org publishes out of the LeRobot record workflow that leLab is the front end for. Across all 1,755 recordings and 72,418 episodes, 255 recordings carry the byte-identical sentence Grasp a lego block and put it in the bin, a sentence 165 separate contributors ship, while every other…

14.1%
Removed
2,404,460 frames . 22.3 hours
165
One sentence
1,108 sentences . 1,070 used by a single contributor
cut 247 of 1,755 (14.1%) across 3 groups8 clips8 tasks x 120 rollouts12 measured claims
box-openerViam Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded viamrobotics/box-opener, the box-opening release your Hugging Face org published and fine-tuned smolvla-box-bot on. All 110 episodes carry the same task string, open box flaps, but the demonstrator speeds up as the session runs, so episode length falls 27% from the first half to the second and the 19 fastest episodes average 19…

17%
Removed
3,782 frames . 6.3 of 49.7 minutes
2.5x
Pace spread
29.6 to 73.6 deg per second
cut 19 of 110 (17.3%) across 3 groups8 clips3 tasks x 170 rollouts9 measured claims
so101-pick-and-placeRerun . 6 Sep 2026

We graded so101-pick-and-place, the pick and place set your org published on Hugging Face. 25,618 of its 52,796 frames, 48.5%, are frames where the six commanded joint angles move under half a degree in total from the frame before, because 70 of the 72 takes are locked inside a 702 to 736 frame window, so the recorder keeps rolling long…

39%
Removed
11.5 of the 29.3 minutes
24.3s
Fixed window
median trailing still run 7.0 s
cut 20,712 of 52,796 (39.2%) across 4 groups8 clips4 tasks x 180 rollouts9 measured claims
IKNet Open Manipulator XTIER IV North America . 6 Sep 2026

I graded youtalk/iknet, the Open Manipulator X recording you committed to your own repo in December 2020, as a demonstration of the method rather than a comment on your current work. The last 10.4 seconds of dataset/train, 1,040 of its 33,186 pose to joint pairs, are the arm resting on the table inside two 5 mm cells with 28 distinct joi…

8.9%
Removed
38 of 420 one second windows
98.0%
Workspace kept
296 of 14,655 lost
cut 3,744 of 41,944 (8.9%) across 3 groups0 clips8 tasks x 120 rollouts10 measured claims
Argoverse 2 SensorOverland AI . 6 Sep 2026

We went through the Argoverse 2 Sensor validation split you co-authored, all 150 logs and all 1,701,935 annotated cuboids. Cuboid size is fixed per track there, and 16,254 distinct sizes cover the 18,395 tracks, except that 1,856 tracks reuse one of just sixteen sizes and 1,427 carry the identical 4.03 by 1.74 by 1.41 metres. Those 1,856…

4.7%
Removed
1,856 tracks . 16 repeated sizes
1,427
One size, 1,427 tracks
54,465 cuboids . median 1 return each . 37.6% hold none
cut 80,172 of 1,701,935 (4.7%) across 4 groups9 clips10 tasks x 130 rollouts11 measured claims
cpaxton/pickup_pink_cupAgility Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded the 20 Stretch dex-teleop takes you published as cpaxton/pickup_pink_cup, recorded off your own cpaxton/readme-updates branch in August 2024. Episode 7 runs the full reach and lift, 0.5714 down to 0.2634 and back up, with the gripper command held at its fully open extreme on all 125 frames, so a pick that grasped nothing sits i…

10.1%
REMOVED
43.3 s of 7 min 11 s
125
GRIPPER HELD OPEN
1 unique value . finger moves 0.0001
10
ACTION VECTOR
agrees to 3e-8 . std 0.29092
cut 260 of 2,587 (10.1%) across 3 groups8 clips6 tasks x 100 rollouts8 measured claims
InstructMove DatasetHorizon Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded your team's InstructMove release on Hugging Face, the whole 500 episode set. In all 300 PiperX dual arm episodes one of the two arms never moves, 7 of the 14 action dimensions hold at most two values from an episode's first frame to its last, and which arm is still flips from episode to episode, 160 left and 140 right. We dropp…

60%
Removed
24.8 minutes of 43.9 minutes
7 of 14
Still half of the action head
160 left arm . 140 right arm . 0 of 8 on Franka
cut 300 of 500 (60.0%) across 4 groups8 clips8 tasks x 120 rollouts9 measured claims
CFG-BenchiRootech . 6 Sep 2026

We went through CFG-Bench, the benchmark your team released and you are a corresponding author on, and gave each of its 9,615 multiple choice items one number, how many of three text-only pickers land on its correct option. Scoring the options by word overlap with your team's released caption for that same video is right 47.2% of the tim…

16.8%
Removed
868 answered by all three pickers . 1,211 of 1,363 videos touched
25.6%
Caption picker after the cut
1,620 of 6,334 kept . 4,540 of 9,615 before
cut 3,281 of 9,615 (34.1%) across 4 groups8 clips11 tasks x 150 rollouts13 measured claims
PhysicalAI-Robotics-GR00T-Teleop-SimXPENG Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

Your UniT and DIAL repos both open data prep by downloading nvidia/PhysicalAI-Robotics-GR00T-Teleop-Sim, so we graded that release, all 24 task directories, 24,000 takes, 5,820,277 frames, 80.84 hours at 20 fps. Every one of the 24 directories declares 1,000 episodes and ships a declared train split that stops at episode 100, the same st…

3.4%
Removed
0.81 of those hours the command never moved
10%
Reached by the declared split
2,400 of 24,000 takes . 9.87% of frames
cut 274 of 24,000 (1.1%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 120 rollouts10 measured claims
TIER IV t4-sampleTIER IV . 6 Sep 2026

We went through the t4-sample release attached to tier4_perception_dataset, the repo you maintain, and read num_lidar_pts on every annotated 3D box in it. 151 of the 658 boxes hold no lidar return at all, and range does not explain it, the median removed box sits 36.8 m from the lidar against 70.6 m for the ones kept. 44 of the 96 boxes…

22.9%
Removed
8 of the 40 object tracks never get a return . 108 of the 151 removed boxes
45.8%
Labelled fully visible, nothing under it
16.1 m median for the fully visible boxes that do have returns
cut 151 of 658 (22.9%) across 4 groups0 clips4 tasks x 180 rollouts11 measured claims
Menlo Robot Hand PosesMenlo Research . 6 Sep 2026

We graded Menlo/robot-hand-poses-train, the corpus your Poseless-3B model card names as its training set. Reading 11,000 of the 100,000 poses, 20.8% of them ask one of the four tendon coupled finger pairs to hold its two joints more than 1.20 rad apart, which one actuator pulling both cannot do, and the worst asks for 1.5638 rad. Two of…

20.8%
Removed
worst pose asks for 1.5638 rad . 89.6 deg
2 of 24
Frozen joints
the other 22 span 0.53 to 2.08 rad
cut 2,293 of 11,000 (20.8%) across 3 groups8 clips7 tasks x 120 rollouts11 measured claims
CMU Motion Capture Library, FBXgBionics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded gbionics/cmu-fbx, the CMU FBX set your team published and the only public dataset in the gBionics org. Scoring all 2,548 rows of metadata.csv by how many clips a query for that exact label returns once case is normalised, 201 carry the literal string Unknown, 98 carry only the word clean, 94 only the word walk, and 5 rows point…

15.6%
Removed
median label reach 201 . 2 for what stays
1,096
Labels kept
4 lost . 68 of 113 subjects untouched
cut 398 of 2,548 (15.6%) across 3 groups0 clips8 tasks x 120 rollouts9 measured claims
UAVScenes key-frame releaseNanyang Technological University . 6 Sep 2026

We went through UAVScenes, the ICCV 2025 release you co-authored with Sijie Wang and the rest of the lab, all 20 flights and all 24,126 hand-labeled camera frames. 1,305 of them, 5.4%, were shot inside a stretch of 3 seconds or longer where the RTK stream has the drone under 0.1 m per second, and a further 386 carry a semantic mask that…

7.0%
Removed
1,305 held still . 386 copied masks
15.6%
One flight loses 15.6%
18.6 min held . longest hold 34.0 s
cut 1,691 of 24,126 (7.0%) across 4 groups8 clips6 tasks x 120 rollouts12 measured claims
FreeTacManOpenDriveLab, University of Hong Kong . 6 Sep 2026

We graded FreeTacMan on OpenDriveLab's Hugging Face org, all 6,428 episodes across the 46 task folders. Every episode reduces to one number, the largest absolute TCP position its own trajectory file writes, and that number splits the release in two with nothing in between, 5,629 episodes run from 197.92 to 542.91 and 799 run from 0.271 t…

12.4%
Removed
1,601 of the 18,484 video files
333x
Scale gap
no episode lands in between
cut 800 of 6,428 (12.4%) across 3 groups8 clips10 tasks x 110 rollouts13 measured claims
WildWorld part 1Shanda / Alaya . 6 Sep 2026

We went through WildWorld part 1, the 3,434 episode release your lab put on Hugging Face, working only from the public file tree. 349 of those episodes spend under 4.54 Mbps on their RGB stream against a 7.57 Mbps median at the same 720p and 30 fps, and 133 of them also land in the lowest tenth of the corpus on the lossless depth stream,…

10.7%
Removed
56.0 of 574 hours . 9.76%
133
Two codecs agree
38.1% of the 349 . 10.3% base rate
cut 368 of 3,434 (10.7%) across 4 groups0 clips8 tasks x 200 rollouts13 measured claims
Small Underwater Objects 3D Point Cloud DatasetKorea Maritime and Ocean University . 6 Sep 2026

We graded the SUOP release your lab published. Object class is recoverable from the byte size of point_cloud.xyz alone for 47.3% of the 1,554 recordings against a 20.5% chance rate, and once range is held fixed that climbs to 69.8% inside the 10 m set, so a model can score by counting points instead of reading shape. We also found 130 re…

8.4%
Removed
2.48 GB of raw sonar . 0.31 GB of point cloud
47.3%
Class from file size
1 nearest neighbour on one scalar . 69.8% inside the 10 m set
cut 130 of 1,554 (8.4%) across 4 groups8 clips8 tasks x 100 rollouts7 measured claims
lerobot/pushtNissan Advanced Technology Center Silicon Valley . 6 Sep 2026

We graded lerobot/pusht, the dataset your lerobot-doctor README runs its worked example on and the default env in lerobot-bench. Your short-episode check reports 2 of 10 on the sample in that README, and at full scale it is 53 of the 206 episodes under the 100-step action chunk ACT uses by default, 4,319 of 25,650 frames, with next.succe…

25.7%
Removed
4,319 of 25,650 frames . 7.2 of 42.8 minutes
0
Success flag
constant False on 206 of 206 episodes
cut 53 of 206 (25.7%) across 4 groups8 clips4 tasks x 160 rollouts10 measured claims
v30_apple_storageRerun . 6 Sep 2026

We graded rerun/v30_apple_storage, the three episode LeRobot v3 fixture in Rerun's Hugging Face org, cut from pollen-robotics/apple_storage. Its meta/info.json declares 14,983 frames and a train split of 0 to 50, which are the parent release's own numbers, while the repo holds 3 episodes and 899 frames, so 14,084 declared frames are not…

58.4%
Removed
17.50 of the 29.97 seconds
16.7x
Header against release
14,084 declared frames are not in the repo
cut 525 of 899 (58.4%) across 3 groups8 clips4 tasks x 150 rollouts11 measured claims
murobotics/tblock-all-piper-clean-v5-bi_piper_followerMuRobotics (HandUMI) . 6 Sep 2026

We graded murobotics/tblock-all-piper-clean-v5-bi_piper_follower, the HandUMI training set your murobotics org published on 5 September. The left gripper action holds a single value from the first frame to the last in 90 of its 176 episodes, 21,820 of 47,539 frames, while the right gripper moves in every episode and never ranges under 28…

51.1%
Removed
21,820 of 47,539 frames . 12.1 of 26.4 minutes
0 of 176
Right gripper flat
left flat in 90 of 176 . right flat in 0 of 176
cut 90 of 176 (51.1%) across 3 groups8 clips5 tasks x 140 rollouts12 measured claims
RAPT G1 OOD BenchmarkUniversity of Queensland . 6 Sep 2026

I graded hmunn/rapt-g1-ood, the release your RAPT README links as its dataset, by reading every episode's length straight out of the npz archive index rather than downloading the arrays. On the 50 run real robot split, log duration by itself separates the 39 anomalous runs from the 11 nominal walks at 0.993 AUROC, and a threshold set at…

10.6%
Removed
30.9 minutes of 53.7 hours
0.993
Length only AUROC
0.58 for the same score on g1_velocity
cut 709 of 6,703 (10.6%) across 4 groups0 clips10 tasks x 100 rollouts11 measured claims
aloha_pen_uncap_diversePhysical Intelligence . 6 Sep 2026

We graded physical-intelligence/aloha_pen_uncap_diverse, the repo openpi hard-codes in its pi0_aloha_pen_uncap config, which your org hosts as a LeRobot conversion of a BiPlay subset recorded at Berkeley. Every one of the 123 episodes is exactly 300 frames, a uniform 6 second window at 50 fps, and the window overruns the demo often enoug…

15.4%
REMOVED
5,700 frames . 1 min 54 s
300
EVERY EPISODE
one bucket . 45.2 s held still
cut 19 of 123 (15.4%) across 4 groups8 clips5 tasks x 200 rollouts12 measured claims
PlayWorld human demonstration dataPrinceton University and Google DeepMind . 6 Sep 2026

We went through the PlayWorld human demonstration release on Tenny Yin's Hugging Face account, the account your lab's open-world repo tells people to download from. Every one of the 925 episodes carries success 1, in all six version and split directories, so that field cannot separate a good demonstration from a bad one, and 102 of them…

15.1%
Removed
10,752 of 64,454 stored frames
925 of 925
Labelled a success
distinct values in that field . 1
cut 140 of 925 (15.1%) across 4 groups8 clips5 tasks x 150 rollouts11 measured claims
robocasa-PnPCounterToSink-MG_100_F_472Holiday Robotics . 6 Sep 2026

We graded robocasa-PnPCounterToSink-MG_100_F_472, a RoboCasa upload owned by DAVIAN Robotics, the group you founded and are still listed in on Hugging Face, not anything from Holiday Robotics. Every episode in it that carries a success label is labeled failure, 472 of 572, and all 472 are exactly 700 frames long, so the label is readable…

55.2%
Removed
every one of them runs the full 35.0 s horizon
82.5%
Ends only at the horizon
all 472 carry a failure label . the other 100 carry no label at all
cut 316 of 572 (55.2%) across 4 groups8 clips10 tasks x 70 rollouts15 measured claims

Release audits

9 releases read as published, with no removal and no retraining. Each one states a counted property of the release itself, so there is no lift number and none is implied. These are the reports that answer what is in a corpus, rather than what removing part of it is worth.

bimanual-table-cleanup, widowxaiExylos

All twelve arm joints read 0.0 for every one of the 3,037 frames of episode 3, which still carries next.success True, while six cameras record the task being completed.

usa-egocentricGrably

561 of 663 VLA action segments span zero time, confirmed twice from start and end frames and from the release's own duration column.

excavator-datasetFlywheel AI

All 176 marker tracking files name a D05 video, and no D05 video exists anywhere in the release. 22 recordings have every marker frozen.

CostNav-Teleop-DatasetMaum AI

Six topics are declared in all 1,639 recordings and carry zero messages in every one, including robot_pose and waypoints.

tblock4NONHUMAN

left_gripper_width is constant for the whole episode in 56 of 122, while the right gripper actuates in every one.

folding_laundryBuild22

A 5,380 frame block carries an episode index that already belongs to a different recording, so 217 of the 453 episodes load frames that are not theirs, with the index, frame number and length all still matching the metadata. Reproduced against lerobot 0.6.1.

Earlier reports

Every report

One line per dataset, 79 of them, across 88 published reports. The two counts differ because a reading is sometimes reissued to a second reader at the same company, and a few public corpora are read by more than one report; those carry a link to each. Where a report's own headline is a measurement it is quoted here verbatim.